Comparison of experiment and calculations

Stabilization of amyloid peptides at the level of dimeric complexes

We have developed a method for increasing the stability of amyloid dimers in order to reduce their ability to enter into further biochemical reactions with the formation of toxic oligomers.

Numerical calculations are presented in the form of a graphical description, which clearly allows you to see an increase or decrease in the stability of dimeric amyloid complexes. Our proposed method allows us to vary the range of stability of dimeric complexes by substitutions of key amino acid residues.

How to determine the stability of the biological complex?

If the dimeric complex is stable, then the formation of high molecular weight structures was much slower.
This was due to the fact that the stable amyloid peptides were in no hurry to enter into chemical reactions with other amyloid peptides to achieve equilibrium.
K16N-K16N
K16N-WT
the Aβ42 K16N peptide was less harmful to neuroblastoma cells than wild-type Aβ42
the mutant Aβ peptide formed predominantly low-n oligomers in vitro
the mutant peptide was highly toxic when mixed in equimolar amounts with wild-type Aβ mixed with wild-type Aβ it aggregated into high-n oliogmers.
A21G-A21G
(Flemish)
a) Aβ peptides carrying the Flemish mutation have relatively low aggregation propensity in vitro, including dimerization
b) Conformational changes are thought to explain the Flemish mutation's inhibitory effect on self-assembly and nucleation.
E22K- E22K
(Italian)
a) Arctic Aβ40 forms protofibrils at an increased propensity and faster rate compared with wild-type Aβ40
b) In Arctic AD brain differentially truncated abundant Aβ is deposited in plaques of variable numbers and shapes in different regions of the brain.
CAA caused by the Italian or Dutch Aβ variants is uniquely characterized by deposition of Aβ in the smooth muscle cells surrounding the cerebral vasculature
E22Q- E22Q
(Dutch)
E22Q-E22Q
(Dutch)
a) The discovery of this mutation was an early demonstration that a variant in the APP gene could cause severe amyloid deposition.
b) Extensive Aβ accumulates in the cerebral vessels, especially the meningeal arteries and the cerebro-cortical arterioles.
c) In vitro, this mutation accelerates Aβ aggregation, leading to increased fibril formation.
d) This mutation is associated with high levels of β-sheet conformation and induction of apoptosis in cerebral endothelial cells compared with wild-type Aβ
[K16N]Aβ42 was found to be less toxic than WT Aβ42 at equal concentrations. However, a mixture of the two adding up to the same concentration was equally or more toxic than WT Aβ42 alone
Fig.5. Oligomerization and toxicity of K16N substituted Aβ peptides.
(1) SH-SY5Y cells were incubated for 12 hours with either 2 μM freshly dissolved peptides (load) of Aβ40 (A) or Aβ42 (B), or oligomers (2–20x) obtained by SEC.

(2) Primary hippocampal neurons were incubated for 48 hours with 2 μM freshly dissolved peptides. Toxicity was determined by percentage of living cells compared to untreated control cells (n = 4–8). The data are presented as mean ± SEM. (*p < 0.001, **p < 0.0001). Reprinted with permission from Kaden et al [97].
[more stable]
It is characterized by high thermodynamic stability compared to other dimers, as well as the least tendency to enter into biochemical reactions to achieve equilibrium. As one of the biological consequences of finding a dimer with high thermodynamic stability, there is a low reactivity, a reduced rate of forming high-molecular complexes, including fibrils and oligomers.
[less stable]
It is characterized by reduced thermodynamic stability compared to other dimers, as well as the greatest tendency to enter into biochemical reactions to achieve equilibrium. As one of the biological consequences of the definition of a dimer with low thermodynamic stability is a high reactivity, an increased rate of formation of high-molecular complexes, including fibrils and oligomers.
Analysis of the stability of amyloid peptides taking into account hereditary mutations. The calculation was performed using the software developed by our team
K16N+K16N _____5,5264
wt-wt ____________5,5372
K16N+wt ________5,5312
E22G- E22G
(Arctic)
[ABeta]2 ______lg(cond(w))
[more stable]
[less stable]
[middle value]
E22K-E22K__ _____5.55431
WT-WT ___________5,5372
[ABeta]2 ______lg(cond(w))
[more stable]
[less stable]
E22G-E22G_ _____5.5492
wt-wt ____________5,5372

[ABeta]2 ________lg(cond(w))
[more stable]
[less stable]
E21G-E21G_ _____5.51966
wt-wt ____________5,5372

[ABeta]2 ________lg(cond(w))
[more stable]
[less stable]
E22K-E22K__ _____5.54094
WT-WT ___________5,5372
[ABeta]2 ______lg(cond(w))
[more stable]
[less stable]
E22K-E22K__ _____5.55431
WT-WT ___________5,5372
[ABeta]2 ______lg(cond(w))
[more stable]
[less stable]
E22K-E22K__ _____5.55431
WT-WT ___________5,5372
[ABeta]2 ______lg(cond(w))
[more stable]
[less stable]
(1)
(2)
K16N+K16N ____________5,5264
wt-wt ___________________5,5372
K16N+wt _______________5,5312

E21G-E21G _____________5,51966
wt-wt ___________________5,5372

E22K-E22K _____________ 5,55431
WT-WT _________________ 5,5372

E22K-E22K _____________5,54094
WT-WT _________________5,5372
Direct Correlation Results Between Numerical Values and Biological Effects
In addition to investigating genetic mutations, we also performed a calculation for random mutations in amyloid peptides and analysed their effect on the half-life of aggregation. Estimated data of lg(cond(W)) value for such mutations are shown in Fig.6 b. The structure with the D23N substitution in the two amyloid peptides represents an antiparallel interaction in the formation of dimer, as opposed to the wild-type structure, whose formation is due to the parallel coupling of amyloid peptides.
Fig.7 Two amyloid peptide structures, with the upper structure corresponding to an interaction between wild-type amyloid peptides, and the lower structure corresponding to an interaction between two mutant forms of D23N peptides, with them forming a dimer by combining into antiparallel structures.
Figure 6: Correlation scheme for physical quantities such as lg(cond(W)) and ∆H. The value of lg(cond(W)) characterizes the stability of the biological complex, and ∆H characterizes the orderliness of the system as the system transitions from one state to another, in this case from the state of the interaction of wild-type amyloid dimers into a system of dimers given the substitutions of the selected amino acid residues.
We will pay special attention to the modified amyloid peptide pair mAβ(11−42)2 (D23N). In this dimer, two symmetric substitutions of D23N were performed. The numerical results are shown in Fig.d extreme value. As can be seen from the presented graphs, the replacement of D23N in the two polypeptide chains results in a sharp decrease in lg(cond(W)), while the ∆H values are conversely in the positive region of values (see Fig.6c). At the same time, the extreme values in the diagram d change significantly (contrast) with the rest of the values in the graph a. The necessary minimum requirement to indicate a significant disruption of molecular bounds and the transition of the system to a new position is the absence of co-directional change in the two quantities lg(cond(W)) and ∆H, which we observe in Fig.6 c and Fig. 6d. The structures of the two wild-type dimers when replacing D23N are shown in Fig.7 .
Method for determining conformational rearrangement by computational methods.

Determination of modified amyloid peptides characterized by the greatest thermodynamic stability.

The second part will be a logical continuation of the search for stable dimeric complexes characterized by thermodynamic stability and a longer aggregation time.
Fig.8. Comparison of experimental and calculated values that characterize the stability of amyloid peptides and their ability to enter into biochemical processes (self-aggregation), depending on the substitutions performed.

Upper graph a) was obtained from the results of the experimental data ( Kinetic aggregation data was kindly provided by Sara Snogerup Linse, Department of Biochemistry and Structural Biology, Center for Molecular Protein Science, CMPS, LUND UNIVERSITY) at a concentration of 1.1 μM. The time of half completion, t1/2, for the serine mutants in comparison with the WT Aβ42 in 20 mM sodium phosphate and 200 μM EDTA at pH 8.0 is shown in the upper graph.

Below them b), c),d) are the corresponding calculated stability data for dimeric complexes taking into account the performed substitutions. At the same time, for clarity of viewing and comparison, the reciprocal value 1/lg(cond(W)) is given.

Thus, we see a relationship between the stability of dimeric modified amyloid peptides and the half-life of their self-aggregation.
Made on
Tilda